In the age of the internet, privacy is an important and controversial issue. But what do privacy rights mean for children? RightsInfo takes a look.
How old were you when you first used the internet?
For a growing number of people, the answer is “under the age of 18.” While privacy concerns exist outside of the internet, its ubiquity has introduced a brave new world of potential violations. This is important because our right to privacy is enshrined in Article 8 of the Human Rights Convention, which guarantees the right to a “private and family life.”
New Technology is Changing Things
Image credit: Hal Gatewood/Unsplash
Initiatives like the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), and the Government’s new Data Protection Act (which brought the GDPR into UK law), have tried to address the new role of technology in our lives, giving us more control over how our data is being used. Still, with the internet extending across national boundaries, some privacy laws can be hard to enforce.
If protecting privacy online is difficult for adults, it’s even more complicated for children. But, with a third of internet users under the age of 18, it’s also a question that’s more important than ever before.
We look at what the law says about how to protect children’s right to privacy and why there are no straightforward solutions.
What Does the Law Say?
Image: Maxime Bhm/ unsplash.com
There are a number of important laws protecting children’s right to privacy. One of the most important is Article 16 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), which states: “No child shall be subjected to arbitrary or unlawful interference with his or her privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to unlawful attacks on his or her honour and reputation.”
Children are also covered by the same protections given to adults in Article 8 of the Human Rights Convention. The value of the UNCRC is that it recognises the unique status and requirements of children, including parental protection and the importance of an education.
Why It’s Complicated
Image credit: Derek Thomson/Unsplash
Under the UK’s new Data Protection Act, which became law in May of this year, children can consent to information services at 13. One of the benefits of this policy is that children are able to engage freely with the internet, which is an important and largely unavoidable tool. However, Ofcom, the government’s communications regulator, points out that children often struggle to distinguish between information and paid content online.
No child shall be subjected to arbitrary or unlawful interference with his or her privacy.
UN Convention on the Rights of the Child
Some critics of the Act argue that, if children aren’t able to recognise advertisements, they also won’t be able fully to understand how companies use their personal data – nullifying consent. There are also practical questions about expecting websites to check the ages of their users.
Another issue is children’s ability to make reasonable choices about what to share about themselves online. Parents will also often share images of their children without asking for consent. Although GDPR guarantees the right to be forgotten, the more something is shared on the internet the more difficult it is to erase.
As so many people who have been filmed saying something regrettable or dancing like (they thought) no one was watching have discovered, once something is online, it tends to stay there.
What More Can Be Done?
While the law guarantees children the right to privacy, the nature of the internet can make that right difficult to enforce.
Rather than trying to keep children off the internet, which – let’s face it – isn’t going to happen, we should be focusing on better educating children in media literacy. Schools and parents must work together to teach children how to protect their privacy online.