Where Does the New Justice Secretary Stand on Human Rights? - RightsInfo

Where Does the New Justice Secretary Stand on Human Rights?

David Lidington has just become our new Justice Secretary, replacing Liz Truss.  Some of the key responsibilities of the role rest around our human rights – prison and court reform, tackling extremism, protecting access to justice and the rule of law are just a few examples. So, what does Mr Lidington think?

The new Justice Secretary has a consistent record of promoting human rights abroad, supporting “the principle that human rights are universal and indivisible”. He’s blogged about freedom of expression and the media overseas, the need to promote human rights in Iran and Syria and has spoken about human rights abuses in China, Burma and Zimbabwe. He’s also regularly talked about international human rights in Parliament and in the press.

During his previous role as Europe Minister, Mr Lidington also praised the Human Rights Convention (though he said the Human Rights Court needed reform):

The Convention and the Court helped protect and entrench rights that we so often take for granted: freedom of religious and political expression; the right to a fair trial; the principle that government, police and prisons are under the law; freedom from unfair discrimination.

In September 2016, speaking as the Leader of the House of Commons, he said “the entire government … stand by the human rights embodied in the European convention, which after all was very much the product of work by United Kingdom jurists and politicians at the time”.

So he supports the Human Rights Act 1998?

Image Credit: Foreign and Commonwealth Office / Flickr

Actually, no. You might think, given his praise of the Human Rights Convention, that Mr Lidington would also support the Human Rights Act. They basically protect the same rights. But the Justice Secretary appears to agree with Theresa May that the Human Rights Act 1998 “has to go” (though this was put on the back burner in the 2017 Conservative manifesto).

In May 2016, Mr Lidington voted to repeal the Human Rights Act. In September 2016, he said that “the human rights of the United Kingdom were well developed, established and had a fine reputation before the enactment of the Human Rights Act 1998”. He’s pointed out that Article 8 has caused particular problems in extradition cases.

What’s his position on some specific human rights?  

Following his appointment at the weekend a number of sources criticised Mr Lidington’s human rights record, with particular focus on his opposition to gay rights.

In 1998, Mr Lidington voted against reducing “the age of consent for homosexual acts” from 18 to 16 (before 2000, the UK had a higher age of consent for homosexuals). In 2003, he voted to keep “Section 28” – the controversial ban on the promotion of homosexuality in schools.

In May 2013, he was one of 154 MPs who voted against gay marriage. He explained his opposition to his local paper, saying that the purpose of marriage was “not only to provide mutual love and commitment but also for the procreation and care of children“. However, he’s open to changing his views: he said in the same interview that he was “mistaken” to have previously voted against civil partnerships.

A quick glance at Mr Liddington’s voting history in Parliament shows his position on a range of other issues including:

Video Credit: BBC Sunday Politics/Twitter

Mr Lidington clearly believes in the principle of human rights, and is proud of the UK’s “high human rights standards“, even if he may not be the Human Rights Act’s biggest fan. Let’s hope he ensures these standards are vigorously protected in his work as Justice Secretary.

Want to know more about the fallout from the election?

Subscribe to RightsInfo and follow us on Facebook and Twitter for more human rights news, views and information.

Image of Mr Lidington: Flickr/ 2.0 Generic

Help us increase understanding and support for human rights in the UK.

About the Author

Rebecca Wright

Rebecca is a barrister and human rights lecturer at the Helena Kennedy Centre for International Justice (Sheffield Hallam). She has worked as a human rights lawyer in countries including Egypt, Afghanistan, Lebanon and Syria. She is a trustee of Freedom from Torture and The Schools Consent Project. She wrote her PhD on the suffragettes. View all posts by Rebecca Wright.
Where Does the New Justice Secretary Stand on Human Rights?
Share this: